There are endless discussions surrounding GMO seeds vs hybrid seeds, heirloom (AKA heritage seeds), and organic seeds. We could talk about all the issues surrounding these hot topics for hours. However, the goal of this article is to cut through the chatter and clear up the confusion surrounding these terms.
GMO Seeds vs Hybrid Seeds
Sifting through all the information on GMO and hybrid seeds can be overwhelming. It’s often hard to tell the truth from corporate America fiction. Let’s blow away the smoke and take an honest, simple look at these terms.
Thinking GMO seeds and hybrid seeds are the same things, or that they are related is a dangerous misconception. Yet, it’s a simple thought to clear up. These two processes could not be more different.
A hybrid is the crossing of two parent plants of the same kind to produce a desired result. Take tomatoes for instance. Say you want a remarkably round, radiantly red tomato. If you cross-pollinate a perfect round tomato with a bright red one, you’ll get a remarkably round, radiantly red tomato! See how that works?
You will see the term “F1 hybrid.” This means plant breeders were able to produce the desired seed in the first generation of cross-breeding. Gardeners achieve this by combining two pure parent lines which have the desired traits.
The breeders pollinate them by hand under row covers, or by using some other form of controlled conditions. Seeds are then harvested from the females. Now you have an F1 hybrid.
Why We Don’t Plant Hybrids
We don’t plant hybrids on Fairhaven Farm. It’s hard to save seeds from them. They’re often sterile. If they are fertile, the likelihood of getting the same plant is iffy.
The seeds you collect can be like only one of the parent plants, or you could get the same plant again. It’s a risk. By the third generation (seeds from the second planting) you will not get the same plant again.
GMOs (genetically modified organisms), also referred to as genetically engineered, which I find interesting. To simplify such a complex issue is challenging. Let’s try anyway.
Unlike hybrids, GMO seeds are created in a lab. Scientists, not farmers, use technical processes like gene splicing. They inject foreign genetic material of one species into the DNA of an unrelated species.
Mixing the DNA of plants, animals, bacteria, herbicides, and/or pesticides. They create combinations that would never happen in nature.
Remember the famous GM tomato spliced with fish and herbicides. Yep, the fish had anti-freeze properties. They wanted the tomato to be frost resistant.
So they injected the fish DNA into the tomato. They added some herbicide, hoping the bugs wouldn’t eat it. Sounds like it would be OK? But DNA alteration, especially between unrelated species, is unpredictable at best.
You can read more about GMOs on TFL.
So now you see that in GMO seeds vs hybrid seeds, not only are they not the same, they’re not even related.
Summary of GMO Seeds vs Hybrid Seeds
Hybrids are created by gardeners crossing the same kind of plants. This process occurs in nature with open-pollinated plants of the same kind. If you plant them too close together, they cross-pollinate creating a hybrid.
GMOs, are created by scientists in a lab. They combine the DNA of unrelated species and chemicals. Things which would never happen in nature.
Someone I respect said, “You don’t need to worry about getting GMO seeds from seed catalogs or your local farm supply. They only come in large bags for commercial farmers.” He was wrong.
Corn, soy, and even zucchini seeds are sold by Monsanto to many seed companies. It does matter what seed you buy and where you buy it.
You cannot save GMOs to replant. Besides the fact that most of them are sterile due to modifications, it is illegal to save seed from GMO crops.
Some farmers have unknowingly had their crops cross-contaminated by a neighbor’s GMO crops. When they saved seeds for replanting their fields, they were sued by Monsanto for illegally saving them. Monsanto won and the farmers lost everything.
Heirloom and Organic Seeds
What about heirloom (AKA heritage) and organic seeds. These two are not near as complicated as GMOs vs hybrids.
An heirloom seed is a seed traceable through generations. They are traced to a time before pesticides and herbicides were used, especially by family farms.
I know what someone is saying. “You can’t know where that seed came from years and years ago.” Well, you’re right, I can’t. That’s why you have to find a seed company you trust. If we have to buy seeds, we have a few companies we support.
We only use heirloom seeds on our farm and buy them as organic seeds whenever available. We save the seeds of these plants for replanting year after year. They always produce the same healthy, hearty plant. This gives us a sustainable seed supply for our farm.
Organic seeds are grown by organic farmers. They have not been exposed to any chemical at any point. They were planted, grown, harvested, and packaged using organic methods only. They can be hybrid or heirloom so watch the wording.
A Few Other Terms
You often see the term open-pollinated used when discussing seeds. Don’t let this confuse you.
Open-pollinated means the plant is pollinated by bees, other insects, wind, and such. The seeds from open-pollinated plants will reproduce new generations of the same plant.
You have to be aware that open-pollinated seeds will cross-pollinate. Planting more than one variety of open-pollinated watermelons, for instance, allows cross-pollination. I made this mistake a few years ago.
I was in a hurry and thought I had separated the watermelons enough to prevent this. The result was a nice Orangello, Ali Baba sweet watermelon cross breed. I couldn’t save seeds that year.
The unique fruit was delicious. I was just disappointed to have to buy watermelon seeds for the next year.
We avoid cross-pollination through three practices.
- We allow enough space between varieties.
- We also use succession planting.
- A helpful tool for us has been the use of pollinating bags.
These three practices help to ensure the viability of our heirloom seeds. Cross-pollination is also preventable by using green houses, row covers, and things like that.
The term pure and natural also appears often when referring to seeds. It means the seed isn’t treated with pesticides, herbicides, or any other chemical, and that it’s not GMO.
This does not mean the seed is organic, but many organic gardeners use this type of seed.
Our Stand on Seeds
There are many places on the worldwide web to find information. You can read for hours and find fact, fantasy, and fear. It’s important to have reliable sources you feel comfortable with and have confidence in. We hope to be one of your sources.
As a homesteader or farmer, you have to decide how you feel about these complex issues. Act on your decision and continue to care for your family.
We face issues with our homesteads that our grandparents and great-grandparents could never imagine. Who would have dreamed choosing a seed for planting would be a major decision?
Have we cleared the air and answered your questions? Do the terms hybrid, GMO, heirloom, and organic make sense to you now? Making your informed decision will be easier once you’ve made the distinctions.
The Farmer’s Lamp and Fairhaven Farm take a firm stand against GMOs. We believe that every person has the right to make their own decision. After all, we each have to live with the consequences of our decisions.
We don’t argue or get confrontational with those who don’t agree with us. If we want to be able to have our own convictions, we must want others to be able to do the same. Our goal is to provide information, share our beliefs and practices with you, and leave the deciding to you. It’s your journey, no one else’s.
Vickie @Vickie's Kitchen and Garden says
I love this information.. there is a lot of confusion. I had a hard time with some seeds and realized they were hybrid. I still love the yield and the taste that I get from them but not being able to save the seed is very discouraging. I love my heirloom because I can save the seed just like my grandma and grandpa did and have them to grow next year. Their is some drying on my table right now! Have a great day!
Thanks Vickie for stopping by to share your experience with us. I’m glad you enjoyed the article. Happy seed saving!
Monsanto and other GMO providing seed companies have patented their seeds, claiming they are unique. This allows them to control distribution and prohibit farmers and even gardeners from saving the seeds to reuse the next season. They can and do, seek legal action against farmers who have done this (saving seeds), often forcing the farmers into bankruptcy. They can do the same to gardeners (although I’ve not heard of this yet), and unfortunately, the courts have upheld Monsanto’s “rights”, rather than the rights of the individual. Even in case when the individual did not knowingly plant the GMO’s.
My point is this: Monsanto says their Roundup ready GMO corn, soy, etc is UNIQUE, and therefore patentable when it is in the hands of farmers. After harvest, Monsanto then tells the consumers the GMO corn, soy, etc, is substantially the same as non-GMO. They even lobby, at great expense, to defeat GMO-labeling laws.
My question is this: If it is so different that Monsanto must protect their seeds at any cost, HOW can it be the same for the CONSUMER? It isn’t. It can’t be both.
You are right, Kathleen, in one of my other articles we talk about that at length. I’m so glad you pointed it out here. Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts with us.